CSF helped the Centro de Asistencia Legal Popular (CEALP) analyze new dams proposed to provide water needed to expand the
Panama Canal. After participating in a CSF training in 1999, CEALP lawyer Erya
Harbar proposed a legal and economic analysis of dams that
would effect both natural ecosystems and campesino communities. The
study examined the economic efficiency and equity of the
proposed $8 billion expansion of the Panama Canal, including new
reservoirs to supply water and electricity. Expanding the canal would
require three new dams, aqueducts, transmission lines and roads in a
remote 500,000-acre area of forest and small towns. The goal of our
work with CEALP was to inform affected rural communities of their
rights and stimulate consideration of the financial and environmental
tradeoffs of the bigger canal in the national policy debate on the
issue.
In
June 2001 CSF and CEALP presented results of our work at a special
forum hosted by the University of Panama. Major conclusions were that
1) the canal expansion would be difficult to finance without heavily
subsidized loans, 2) borrowing for the canal project would induce
macroeconomic imbalance and displace social spending, and 3)
environmental and social consequences were likely to be understated due
to a low estimate of the number of people living in the project area. In 2007 Panamanian voters opted for a revised canal expansion proposal, which will use water recycling to lower environmental impacts as well as the project costs.